MK ATLAS· Science Atlas

Concepts explained

Why Charge Does Not Change — The Bookkeeping of a Lightning Bolt

Electricity is not made; it is moved. Charge conservation was born the moment Franklin wrote, in 1752, that electricity is one fluid of which there is only more or less. The sum of positive and negative charge has never changed since the universe began.

Questions this piece threads together 43 min readUpdated 2026-10-13

Lightning — a transfer of charge between cloud and ground
Hansueli Krapf · CC BY-SA 3.0 · Wikimedia Commons

is the property that attracts and repels electrically, and it comes in two kinds, positive and negative. Charge conservation says this: inside a closed region, positive charge minus negative charge never changes. Charge can be neither made nor destroyed, only moved, or made and destroyed in pairs.

1752: the man who wrote that electricity is one thing

Until the mid-eighteenth century electricity was thought to be of two kinds, vitreous and resinous. Benjamin Franklin saw it differently: electricity is a single fluid, and each body simply holds more of it than usual (positive) or less (negative). When one body gains, another loses. That sentence is the first statement of charge conservation.

Franklin had to decide which side was the 'more' side, and called rubbed glass positive. A century later it was learned that the particle actually moving, the electron, carried the opposite sign. That is why, even now, the direction of current and the direction electrons move are opposite. His guess was half wrong; the idea of conservation was wholly right.

1785: the man who turned charge into a number

To speak of conservation you must measure the quantity. With a torsion balance Coulomb measured that the force between two charges falls as the square of the distance and grows as the product of the charges. From then on charge was a quantity you could say 'how much' of, and conservation became a testable law.

Faraday showed in electrolysis that the charge passed and the amount of substance deposited on the electrode were exactly proportional: the first hint that charge is something countable, like grains. The charge that flowed piled up somewhere; it did not vanish.

The only way to make charge from nothing

In the twentieth century charge conservation faced a stricter test. When sufficiently energetic light (a gamma ray) passes near an atomic nucleus, the light vanishes and two particles appear. Matter made from nothing. But they always appear as a pair: an electron (negative) and a positron (positive). Their combined charge is zero; the light's charge was zero. The books balance. The partner is , predicted by Dirac's equation in 1928 and observed in 1932.

In reverse, when an electron and a positron meet, both vanish and only light remains: charge −1 and +1 have combined to zero. In trillions of particle experiments this ledger has never once been found wrong. Charge conservation is among the most precisely tested of all known conservation laws.

Why it does not change

The symmetries of the previous three pieces were visible: time, position, direction. The symmetry behind charge is not. The equations describing electric and magnetic fields contain a hidden dial called 'phase', and the laws of physics are the same wherever that dial is set. By , the conserved quantity that follows from that is charge. Charge is conserved because the laws of electromagnetism contain one dial we are free to set as we like.

This idea of a hidden symmetry (gauge symmetry) became the backbone of particle physics in the late twentieth century. Charge conservation is its first instance.

If you know this does not change, what can you find out?

1The charge of an unseen particle

Since total charge must match before and after a reaction, the charge of a particle the detector missed can be deduced. That the neutrino is neutral was settled this way.

2The electron cannot die

There is no lighter charged particle for it to decay into, so the electron has nowhere to go. Charge conservation is why the electron is stable.

3The laws of circuits

Kirchhoff's rule that current in equals current out at a junction is charge conservation applied to wires. All electronic circuit design stands on it.

4The neutrality of the universe

That the total charge of the universe is near zero means positive and negative were made only in pairs at the beginning. Charge tells us the Big Bang's books balanced.

Energy, momentum, angular momentum, charge: four unchanging quantities. The last piece is different. A quantity believed unchanging for two hundred years, then found to change: mass.

The question that remainsWhy does charge exist only in units of one electron's charge? Conservation says only that the sum does not change; it says nothing about why charge comes in grains. The question is still open.