MK ATLAS· Science Atlas

Concepts explained

When You Don't Know, Hold On to What Doesn't Change — A Physicist's Shoes and the Conservation Laws

Asked what to hold on to in a world changing this fast, a physicist brought out a pair of ten-year-old shoes. That, in truth, is what physics has been doing for three hundred years: finding the quantities that refuse to change in a turbulent world, and resting a hand on them.

Questions this piece threads together 34 min readUpdated 2026-10-13

Star trails over Kitt Peak — only Polaris stays put
KPNO/NOIRLab/NSF/AURA · CC BY 4.0 · Wikimedia Commons

This piece begins from that sentence. Heard as advice for living, it is simply good advice. What makes it interesting is that a physicist said it, because physics has been doing exactly that for three hundred years: in a world where everything moves, breaks, burns and cools, finding the quantities that do not change at all.

Physics gave those quantities a name: . This series looks at five of them, one at a time. This piece is the preface: why 'what does not change' is so precious, and what knowing it makes possible.

The logic of a pair of shoes

Look again at his examples. Ten-year-old shoes, books under three hundred pages, a red ballpoint. They share something: each is a thing he controls, and a thing certain to be the same tomorrow. The shoes will still fit; the pen will still write.

He is not a man who dislikes change. Someone who teaches and writes about quantum mechanics cannot dislike change. His point was different: when too much is changing to keep up with all of it, where should a person stand? The answer: on the spot that does not move.

The physicists did the same thing

Eighteenth-century chemists did not know where firewood went when it burned. The ash weighed far less than the wood. Something seemed to vanish. Lavoisier did not believe in the vanishing. He sealed glass vessels and weighed everything before and after burning. The weights matched. In place of what he did not know (what fire is) he took hold of what did not change (), and rebuilt chemistry on it.

In the nineteenth century the problem was heat. Was heat a substance or a motion? Nobody knew. Joule stirred water with paddles and measured how much it warmed. The amount of done and the amount of heat produced were always in the same ratio. Without knowing what heat was, one could know that work and heat added together did not change. That is the conservation of .

In the early twentieth century, energy seemed to go slightly missing when atomic nuclei broke up. There were two roads: abandon energy conservation, or believe that an unseen particle was carrying the missing energy away. Pauli chose the second, judging that believing in a particle no one had seen was less mad than abandoning a conservation law. Twenty-six years later that particle, the neutrino, was detected.

The three did the same thing. When much was unknown, they held on to what did not change. And what did not change became the guide to finding what was unknown.

Why it does not change — the answer of 1918

But why do those quantities not change? For a long time it was simply a fact: nature is like that. In 1918 the mathematician Emmy Noether found the reason. Wherever nature has a , a conserved quantity necessarily follows.

If 'symmetry' sounds difficult, rephrase it: 'the result is the same whenever you run the experiment.' A stone dropped today and a stone dropped tomorrow fall at the same rate. That obvious fact is the symmetry of time, and by Noether's theorem it gives birth to the conservation of energy. 'The same wherever you run it' gives conservation of momentum; 'the same whichever way you turn the apparatus' gives conservation of angular momentum.

Where this series goes

The five pieces that follow take five unchanging quantities one at a time: energy, momentum, angular momentum, electric charge, and mass. The last is special. The mass conservation Lavoisier established was demoted after Einstein to a law that is 'almost right'. That piece tells how something believed unchanging turned out to change under certain conditions.

Every piece closes with the same question: if you know this does not change, what can you find out? Conservation laws are precious not because they are beautiful in themselves but because knowing them lets you find what has not yet been seen. As Pauli found the neutrino.

So, back to the shoes. A man in ten-year-old shoes teaches quantum mechanics. There is no contradiction. You have to stand on what does not change in order to see clearly what does. That is what physics has done for three hundred years, and what one physicist said in an interview.

When you don't know, hold on to what doesn't change.The gist of Kim Sang-wook's interview on the programme Jisikin Chodaeseok (host Han Seok-jun), compressed by this piece into one sentence
The question that remainsWe now know why energy, momentum and charge do not change: symmetry. Then what, in our own lives, is 'the same whenever you do it', and what quantity does it protect?